Marchmont network: business news | conferences | consulting
Marchmont blog Eng | Рус

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Russia may jerk two steps forward and one step back—but hardly to a halt

More thoughts on Russia’s innovation development patterns in the wake of my prior posting from a couple of weeks ago…

Russia, in the last twenty years, has gone through fundamental transformation—from the commodity-driven economy to having now a strong national interest in developing the innovation-driven economy. We’re not there yet; there’s a lot of work to do. But there’s a critical mass of people that say Russia has no choice but to develop the innovation-driven economy.

The economy model based on commodities cannot work. The level of volatility is simply too high in such an economy for any government or culture to survive the ups and downs. If the global economy is on upward momentum, and oil prices are high, Russia does great; everybody’s just in a very wonderful mood. But if the global economy turns down, Russia may turn down three times worse than the rest of the world.

In this type of up and down momentum, and lack of stability in the foundations of the economic structure, Russian investors have had very short time horizons. They are worried about inflation, volatility; they’re worried of whether the government will change too abruptly. And all those worries create high levels of risk. Those risk levels make barriers for investors to think long-term.

That’s what has to change. And it’s changing. Russia’s developing fundamental basics of a structure to support innovation development at the grassroots—at the individual innovation leaders’ level—through education programs, through Eureka programs, through US-Russia Foundation programs. These types of programs to support fundamental law and civil society and institutional structures of democracy are critical for Russia’s long-term development.

All the people that I know in private enterprise and innovation entrepreneurship understand it well. And the people at the top who I’ve talked to also believe and understand this. But one must remember there’s a lot of people in the middle that have no vested interest in this future—people that thrive in chaos and ‘gray’ markets, and do well on corruption and kickbacks. They are not very interested in the type of society which is fully transparent and stable and long-term growth oriented.

Society is divided in Russia, and any observer of this country has to understand this.

There’re those who are for the process going forward; these are the young generation, innovators, entrepreneurs, doctors, lawyers—the professionals. They want to see a new society.

But there’s an older generation, and there’s an entrenched generation of bureaucrats and security service people that don’t really want to see the system change.

The situation isn’t clear-cut in Russia. The people have not decided as a strong majority, “This is what we want to do.” But we have to be on the side of the young generation that wants to move forward. The older generation wants stability and is prepared to sacrifice freedoms and human rights in order to have that stability. But young people, as in all cultures, are ready to risk it all in order to get more freedoms.

That’s what we have to support. I think that’s what we are supporting. And I think that’s what the world has to support in Russia. We shouldn’t take a critical eye and just condemn Russia that it’s not working out. It is working out. We’ve gone through twenty years of an extremely complex and difficult transitionary process. But the world has to realize that Russia needs to go through twenty more years.

We have to be patient with Russia; we have to work with Russia; we have to help Russia through this; we have to help its young generation. We have to understand that there are those in society that do not support what we’re doing. And they don’t want to support that because it’s against their interests. People that make a lot of money through non-transparent transactions don’t want the light of day shed on their work. We have to accept that that is reality in Russia that we have to deal with. But the people I work with, and the people I’ve met and been close to over the last twenty years, understand this and support the move forward.

I encourage any observer of Russia to really look at the situation with clear eyes, not rose-colored glasses, and not cynical glasses either. It’s easy to look at Russia and criticize; it’s easy to look at Pussy Riot like scandals and think, “Oh, Russia’s judicial system is just a mess!” Well, there are problems, but there are problems all across society. There are bright spots, however. There are lots of arbitration suits which are decided in favor of the Western investors; there are even those that uphold IP and trademark rights (take a look at a recent interesting one, with a Swiss watchmaker, Longines, awarded damages from a Russian delinquent online store in a trademark infringement suit). One must look at the overall picture and draw broad conclusions.

Russia is moving in a certain direction. It’s not negative. It’s two steps forward and one step back. It’s easy to point out the steps backward; but one should not forget we are making steps forward.

I remember when there were lines for bread and sausages in Russia; and it was chaos and hyper-inflation. Those times are long gone. Today, we live in a different world. Today, we’re talking about nuances, “How much freedom do innovators have? What type of tax incentives do business angels have to invest and risk their money in high technology?”

These are the real debates we’re facing today. And those are serious and need level-headed assessments on how to change the legal structure in Russia. Because in the end, it’s all about the rules of the game, and what rules we set for ourselves in developing this innovation economy in Russia. This comes back to the rule of law; this comes back to the judiciary and political structure. What we need to be focused on is helping Russia develop a proper set of rules to motivate and guide investors to make the right decisions, to make the decisions to invest in Russia.

That means that the government needs to consider that those investors have lots of alternatives in this world. They can invest in derivatives, or currencies, and speculate in any part of the world they want. So, if Russia wants investors to invest in this country, it has to create conditions that attract investors into this economy. And not only foreign investors but Russian investors.

This is what Russia has to face over the next five years. And I believe the next five years is the single most critical period we ever faced. Because if Russia continues to lose three or four hundred thousand young innovators, its ‘brain trust’ that now leaves Russia, this will be a catastrophe for this country. The top leadership and the elites in Russia understand that. So what we have to do is help Russia develop the right policy which will stimulate domestic young innovators to stay in the country and to work and develop their businesses.                


  1. Very nice blog post. Besides as I see, this post is really helpful for some students so. I believe author view about this subject and that I assume that it'd be really attention-grabbing to form such talk with different this web site guests. It is one of the finest websites I have stumbled upon. It is not solely well developed, but has good content as well. It may influence be a thought for some special clients. Anyway thanks tons a new time for the nice and helpful web log post. And I will surely be waiting extra such nice posts like this one from you. You are only one click far-off from your required work. Just come on site and order your work. We will offer you the simplest thesis writing services, which shows the value that you need. All your work is provided you on time. If you're feeling that, we have no proper and skilled staff that write the perfect thesis for you, and they do not feel pause just take the question about our custom essay writing service. Every single student is checking out a correct essay maker who will perceive the necessity of the work and do the essay fully flawed. However, it often happens that students fail to figure out who can be one of the best instant essay types for their work. You may conceive to try to get a social science study paper on-line somewhere however you wish to bear in mind of some things. Those sites can supply social science papers purchasable however they need been sold to many people. You have no plan anywhere those papers came from and who wrote them. You do not know the college level of the writer and chances are you will have to spend time tweaking the paper to your tutor’s terms. For that sort of problem you may still simply write the paper yourself.

  2. Hello guys, being a student of international relations is quite mportant and useful for me to find such kind of essays at the internet, because you see that it is pretty hard to find a good and quality info judging the fact that there are a lot of waste information that is quite unnecessar, but yours it is not the same, it is quite good, and it will be a good addition for my paper, which was written for me by writers from papers-land affiliate
    Ohhh and just not to forget, i want to say that you can simply surf their site and find different artciles for free which can be also quite a good base for you

  3. I got to browse your book a few months ago and I can say that is very well-written. You deserve to be in the top spot.
    Visit us for online one sided visiting card printing

  4. Can you tell me more reasons why this should work for our business that sells osrs gp?

  5. Innovation is both exciting and risky. It becomes even more complicated in a place like Russia, where you have to fight against the odds and the status quo to make an innovative idea successful. As a student of economics, I am interested in finding out how innovation impacts the overall economic performance of a country. The process of researching is fun for me and those who hire a university essay writing service, miss out on the fun and an opportunity to learn.


  6. debby clarke belichick is the ex-wife of New England Patriots’ head coach Bill Belichick and the mother of three children; want to know more about her then this article is for you

  7. I was studying about the Russian economy because I was given an assignment to write about the economical structure of Russia, keeping in consideration the momentum of its development or underdevelopment over the years but I needed data to support what I wrote. I contacted the online assignment services who function with the best writers and specialised data analysts who could produce the statistical data I required in charts and tables, provided authenticity and reliability

  8. you don`t have to worry about plagiarism. Our writers will formulate error and plagiarism free essays for your college because we know how teachers are making use of new cutting edge, plagiarism detection technologies. professional assignment writer

  9. When I originally commented I clicked the "Notify me when new comments are added" checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Many thanks!flat foot

  10. Hello everyone, my name is John Jones and I would like to tell you about memos. The biggest competitor to reminders are emails. One of the key reasons is that landmarks are starting to disappear from offices, as e-mails are receiving much more attention. Sending emails is convenient and easy, no matter who the sender or recipient is. No need to print and then distribute thousands of memos if you have email at hand. If you intersted this follow this link and see more about memos!

  11. Hello, I would like to thank you for sharing your personal blog. The point you have stressed here about the innovations and politics is rather great. I found another source where the same points are discussed but from another point of view.

  12. Homework Helper We are well aware of the pressures that college and university students have to face during their academic years.


  13. Thanks for a marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you might be
    a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will
    often come back at some point. I want to encourage yourself to continue your great posts,
    have a nice day!

    my web page; 부산오피

  14. If you want to find best writing service which can write such interesting blog posts you can just google and ask for help.

  15. Customs clearance is estimated at 3.65. This indicates a satisfactory performance - the customs clearance procedure is generally effective, although sometimes it can be a problem for a long time;

  16. Hi guys! Thank you for sharing interesting facts about Russia and the developing Russian economy. I must say this info it's very interesting and students can read these tips and pre written essays online on and write your own paper. If you need to write an essay but haven't time you should ask for writing help and their writers can help you. When I order my essay they are guaranteed the quality of written papers and I have the opportunity to check my essay before delivery.

  17. This post is quite informative, and I much learn about Russian culture On this website, I always see quality-dependent articles. I also follow you. I want to be the best blogger like you—every time I like to read your writing stuff like I get help from Take My Class Online For Me, because I get very useful content there. You do great work.

  18. The information you shared in this blog is very good and useful to me and many others. It is closely related to my work and helped me to grow!! You've done truly a great and awesome work dear and also Thanks for sharing this blog!! qalamkar winter collection.

  19. For the very first time, I read your blog and loved it. Your way of delivering content is amazing and appreciable. Hope you will continue this and provide new, unique, and strong content from your side. For me, it’s a five stars article. local seo company.

  20. now a days Russia and Ukraine war create high panic in all over the world every business industry faced many challenges in this time international media said all Global B2b Manufacturers decided they break our work till end of war.

  21. I was studying some of your articles on this site and I think this web site is really informative! Keep putting up안전놀이터

  22. heyy !!!
    tis is anaa and i was searching the best aviation parts store then i stopped here and started reading this post. i must say this is so amazing.

  23. No doubt this is an excellent post! I got a lot of knowledge after reading this, thank you!

  24. Thank you so much for sharing. I have found it extremely helpful!
    Regards: Hotel Kirkland